Appendix 1

Assessment of Comparative Effectiveness of the Russian Federation Regions Nationalities Policy

Region

Index of ethnic minorities' policy effectiveness (EEMPIi)*

Index of ethnic minorities' policy infrastructure development (IEMPIi)**

Including values for the following blocks:

Laws and legislation (Li)

Programs of nationalities policy (Pi)

Practical policy (POi)

Institutional foundations (INi)

Funding (Fi)

Perm

0,655

0,825

0,233

0,920

0,800

0,733

0,960

Komi

0,629

0,703

0,450

0,800

0,700

0,617

0,634

Udmurtia

0,593

0,679

0,417

0,600

0,900

0,500

0,653

Samara

0,588

0,772

0,167

0,920

1,000

0,567

0,805

Saratov

0,588

0,674

0,333

0,800

0,800

0,567

0,580

Volgograd

0,572

0,647

 

0,600

0,820

0,900

0,333

 

Buryatia

0,452

0,542

0,333

0,500

0,600

0,283

0,663

Stavropol

0,440

0,535

0,167

0,600

0,800

0,567

0,363

Sverdlovsk

0,435

0,560

0,167

0,600

1,000

0,333

0,465

Chuvashia

0,421

0,482

0,250

0,600

0,600

0,583

0,251

Tomsk

0,406

0,486

0,167

0,600

0,500

0,500

0,444

Orenbourg

0,395

0,490

0,167

0,600

0,800

0,567

0,213

Rostov

0,357

0,420

0,167

0,500

0,400

0,450

0,389

Moscow region

0,350

0,422

0,167

0,400

0,700

0,333

0,340

Tver

0,329

0,439

0,167

0,400

0,860

0,167

0,401

Kabardinian-Balkar Republic

0,307

0,342

0,300

0,400

0,460

0,233

0,213

Tataria

0,282

0,426

0,083

0,400

1,000

0,167

0,319

Adyghea

0,279

0,357

0,167

0,300

0,800

0,200

0,213

Penza

0,270

0,301

0,250

0,200

0,400

0,333

0,214

Amur

0,224

0,264

0,167

0,200

0,400

0,167

0,256

Moscow city

0,201

0,630

0,002

0,600

1,000

0,450

0,733

Astrakhan

0,177

0,508

0,002

0,600

0,800

0,533

0,403

Bashkiria

0,152

0,432

0,002

0,400

0,800

0,450

0,338

Nizhni Novgorod

0,123

0,323

0,002

0,400

0,500

0,400

0,208

Irkutsk

0,105

0,306

 

0,400

0,600

0,117

0,275

 

Kransnodar

0,093

0,305

0,002

0,400

0,500

0,567

0,038

Tula

0,051

0,110

0,083

0,200

0,100

0,167

0,001

Dagestan

0,041

0,251

0,002

0,200

0,600

0,450

0,001

Voronezh

0,000

0,000

0,000

0,000

0,000

0,000

0,000

* This value is calculated as a geometric mean of particular indices for blocks and characterizes a effectiveness of nationalities (a balance among development of different blocks).

** This value is calculated as an arithmetic mean of particular indices for blocks and characterizes a potential of nationalities policy.